• Home
  • About
  • Contact
Saturday, July 19, 2025
  • Login
based underground
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
based underground
No Result
View All Result

PCLOB ‘Book Report’ Fails to Investigate or Tell the Public the Truth About Domestic Mass Surveillance

by EFF
June 30, 2021
0 0
PCLOB 'Book Report' Fails to Investigate or Tell the Public the Truth About Domestic Mass Surveillance

The Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board (PCLOB) has concluded its six-year investigation into Executive Order 12333, one of the most sprawling and influential authorities that enables the U.S. government’s mass surveillance programs. The result is a bland, short summary of a classified report, as well as a justified, scathing, and unprecedented unclassified statement of opposition from PCLOB member Travis LeBlanc.

Article by Matthew Guariglia and Cindy Cohn from EFF.

America First Healthcare

Let’s start with the fact that the report is still classified—the PCLOB is supposed to provide public access to its work “to the greatest extent” consistent with the law and the needs of classification.  Yet the public statement here is just 26  pages describing, rather than analyzing, the program. Nothing signals to the public a lack of commitment to transparency and a frank assessment of civil liberties violations like blocking the public from even reading a report about one of the most invasive U.S. surveillance programs.

Member LeBlanc rightly points out that, at a minimum, the PCLOB should have sought to have as much of its report declassified as possible, rather than issuing what he correctly criticizes as more like a “book report” than an expert legal and technical assessment.

The PCLOB was created after a recommendation by the 9/11 Commission to address important civil liberties issues raised by intelligence community activities. While its first report about Section 215 was critical in driving Congress to scale back that program, other PCLOB reports have been less useful. EFF sharply disagreed with the Board’s findings in 2014 on surveillance under FISA Section 702, especially where it found that the Section 702 program is sound “at its core,” and provides “considerable value” in the fight against terrorism—despite going on to make ten massive recommendations for what the program must do to avoid infringing on people’s privacy.

But even by the standards of past PCLOB reports, this latest report represents a new low, especially when addressing the National Security Agency’s XKEYSCORE. XKEYSCORE is a tool that the NSA uses to sift through the vast amounts of data it obtains, including under Executive Order 1333. As the Guardian reported in 2013 based upon Edward Snowden’s revelations, XKEYSCORE gives analysts the power to watch—in real time—anything a person does on the Internet. There are real issues raised by this tool and, as LeBlanc notes, other than by the PCLOB, the XKEYSCORE program is “unlikely to be scrutinized by another independent oversight authority in the near future.”

Geopolitical turmoil has prompted price hikes for long-term storage survival food. Heaven’s Harvest is the exception because their all-American food is sourced locally. Use promo code “Patriot” for a nice discount today!

LeBlanc writes that his opposition to the report stems from:

  1. The unwillingness of the investigation into Executive Order 12333 to scrutinize modern technological surveillance issues, such as algorithmic decision making, and their impact on privacy and civil liberties;
  2. A failure of the Board majority to investigate and evaluate not just how XKEYSCORE can query online communications that the NSA already has, but the legal authority and technological mechanisms that allow it to collect that data in the first place;
  3. The decision to leave out of the report any analysis of the actual effectiveness, costs, or benefits of XKEYSCORE;
  4. The haphazard and unthoughtful way the NSA defended its legal justification for the program’s use—and the Board’s unwillingness to probe into any possible issues of compliance;
  5. A vote to exclude LeBlanc and Board member Ed Felten’s additional recommendations from the report;
  6. The unwillingness of the Board to attempt to declassify the full report or inform the public about it, which LeBlanc labels as “inexcusable,” and,
  7. The unconventional process by which the Board voted to release the report.

Any one of these concerns would be significant.Taken together they are a scathing indictment of an oversight board that appears to be unable or unwilling to exercise actual oversight.

As LeBlanc notes, there is so much about XKEYSCORE and the NSA’s operations under Executive Order 12333 that require more public scrutiny and deep analysis of their legality. But it seems impossible to achieve this under the current regime of overbroad secrecy and PCLOB’s refusal to play its role in both analyzing the programs and giving the public the information it needs. LeBlanc rightly notes that the report ignores the “collection” of information and that both collection and querying “are worthy of review for separate legal analysis, training, compliance and audit processes.” As we have long argued, this analysis is important “whether the collection and querying activities are performed by humans or machines.”

He also notes that the PCLOB failed to grapple with so-called “incidental” collection—how ordinary Americans are caught up in mass surveillance even when they are not the targets. And he notes that the PCLOB failed to investigate compliance and accepted a legality analysis of XKEYSCORE by the NSA’s Office of General Counsel that appears to only have been written after the PCLOB requested it, despite the program operating for at least a decade before. What’s more, the review fails to take into consideration the Supreme Court’s more modern analysis of the Fourth Amendment. Those are just some of his concerns—all of which we share.

Nor did the PCLOB analyze the effectiveness of the program. Basic questions remain unanswered, like whether this program has ever saved any lives. Or whether, like so many other mass surveillance programs, any necessary information it gathered could not be gathered in another manner? These are all important questions that we deserve to know—and that at least one member of the PCLOB board agrees we deserve to know.

On December 4, 1981, Ronald Reagan signed Executive Order 12333, which gave renewed and robust authorities to the U.S. intelligence community to begin a regime of data collection that would eventually encompass the entire globe. Executive Order 12333 served as a damning pivot after less than a decade of reforms and mea culpas. The 1975 report of the Church Committee revealed, and attempted to end, three decades of lawless surveillance, repression, blackmail, and sabotage that the FBI, CIA, and NSA wrought onto Americans and the rest of the world. Executive Order 12333 returned the intelligence community to its original state: legally careless, technically irresponsible, and insatiable for data.

Twenty-three years after Reagan signed Executive Order 12333, PCLOB was established as a counterbalance to the intelligence community’s free reign over the years. But it’s clear that despite some early achievements, the PCLOB is not living up to its promise. That’s why cases like EFF’s Jewel v. NSA, while not about XKEYSCORE or Executive Order 13333 per se, are critically important to ensure that our constitutional and statutory rights remain protected by the courts, since independent oversight is failing. But at minimum, the PCLOB owes the public the truth about mass surveillance—and even its members are starting to see that.



New Conservative Network Seeks Crowdfunding Help

They say we have to go big or go home. We’re trying to go big and bring the patriotic truth the the nation, but we need help.

Readers may or may not realize that over the past year, we’ve been bringing more conservative news and opinion outlets under our wing. Don’t take our expansion as a sign of riches; all of the “acquisitions” have been through sweat and promises of greater things to come for all involved. As a result, we’ve been able to bring together several independent media sites under a unified vision of preventing America from succumbing to the progressive, “woke,” Neo-Marxist ideologies that are spreading like wildfire across America.


  • The Potential of Ivermectin and Mebendazole in Treating Parasites and Beyond


The slow and steady reopening of America is revealing there was a lot more economic hardship brought about from the Covd-19 lockdowns than most realize. While we continue to hope advertising dollars on the sites go up, it’s simply not enough to do things the right way. We are currently experiencing a gap between revenue and expenses that cannot be overcome by click-ads and MyPillow promos alone (promo code “NOQ” by the way).

To overcome our revenue gap and keep these sites running, our needs fluctuate between $3000-$7000 per month. In other words, we’re in the red and hemorrhaging.

The best way you can help us grow and continue to bring the truth to the people is by donating. We appreciate everything, whether a dollar or $10,000. Anything brings us closer to a point of stability when we can hire writers, editors, and support staff to make the America First message louder. Our Giving Fuel page makes it easy to donate one-time or monthly. Alternatively, you can donate through PayPal as well.

As the world spirals towards radical progressivism, the need for truthful journalism has never been greater. But in these times, we need as many conservative media voices as possible. Please help keep NOQ Report and the other sites in the network going.

Thank you and God Bless,
JD Rucker

Bitcoin: 32SeW2Ajn86g4dATWtWreABhEkiqxsKUGn






Why One Survival Food Company Shines Above the Rest

Let’s be real. “Prepper Food” or “Survival Food” is generally awful. The vast majority of companies that push their cans, bags, or buckets desperately hope that their customers never try them and stick them in the closet or pantry instead. Why? Because if the first time they try them is after the crap hits the fan, they’ll be too shaken to call and complain about the quality.

It’s true. Most long-term storage food is made with the cheapest possible ingredients with limited taste and even less nutritional value. This is why they tout calories so much. Sure, they provide calories but does anyone really want to go into the apocalypse with food their family can’t stand?

This is what prompted the Llewellyns to launch Heaven’s Harvest. They bought survival food from multiple companies and determined they couldn’t imagine being stuck in an extended emergency with such low-quality food. They quickly discovered that freeze drying food for long-term storage doesn’t have to mean sacrificing flavor, consistency, or nutrition.

Their ingredients are all-American. In fact, they’re locally sourced and all-natural! This allows their products to be the highest quality on the market, so good that their customers often break open a bag in a pinch to eat because they want to, not just because they have to due to an emergency.

At Heaven’s Harvest, their only focus is amazing food. They don’t sell bugout bags, solar chargers, or multitools. They have one mission – feeding Americans in times of crisis.

What they DO offer is the ability for people to thrive in times of greatest need. On top of long-term storage food, they offer seeds to help Americans for the truly long-term. They want them to grow their own food if possible which is why they offer only Heirloom, Non-GMO, Non-Hybrid, Open-Pollinated seeds so their customers can build permanent food security on their own property.

Visit the Heaven’s Harvest website and use promo code “Patriot” for a discount today!

Tags: Domestic SurveillanceEFFExecutive Order 12333NSAPCLOBPrivacy and Civil Liberties Oversight BoardTop Story
Next Post
Innocent Man Arrested, Held on $50K Bail for Holding Up a Sign in Public

Innocent Man Arrested, Held on $50K Bail for Holding Up a Sign in Public

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact

© 2021 based underground.