Based Underground is now a conservative news aggregator AND curated newsletter.
(DCNF)—Former federal prosecutor Andy McCarthy said there is a “faction” of jurors in the Daniel Penny trial that have bought into Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s alleged racial narrative.
Jurors told Judge Maxwell Wiley on Friday that they were at a “deadlock” in their deliberations on the verdict, leading the judge to dismiss the second-degree manslaughter charge and leave the lesser charge of criminally negligent homicide up for consideration. As the jurors continued their deliberations Monday, McCarthy told “America’s Newsroom” that the trial will likely result in a mistrial due to several jurors believing in Bragg’s “racialized” framing of the case.
“Let’s remember what Bragg was pushing for up until Friday was the recklessness charge which carried a 15-year penalty,” McCarthy said. “So, I don’t see any change in the position of the DA, I see a change in the strategy of someone who couldn’t get the count that he was pushing for so now he’s onto this other count. But as far as this overcharging is concerned, look, we’ve spent a lot of time talking about two cases from Bragg. This case, where he overcharged it to push for a compromised verdict, and the other case which was at most a single transaction business record case and turned it into 34 felonies. So that’s what we’re dealing with here.”
“You have to wonder if some jurors think that they’re basically being brought back to court everyday until they finally convict this guy of something,” McCarthy continued. “My own view of it is that you probably have two factions on the jury, one that’s bought into this racialized presentation by the DA’s office that wants Penny convicted because [Jordan] Neely died whether Penny was actually responsible for that or not, and then you have another faction of jurors who think nothing should happen here, this guy should be acquitted. And what I assume is probably going to happen is after a day or two, it will be clear that we have a stalemate there will be a mistrial. I’d like to see him get acquitted, but it’s hard to believe that’ll happen given that there were some jurors, at least one, who was willing to convict him on the recklessness which I don’t even think there’s any evidence for.”
Bragg charged Penny, a 26-year-old former Marine, over the death of 30-year-old homeless man Jordan Neely after the defendant restrained him in a chokehold on a subway in New York City in May 2023. Neely allegedly screamed at commuters in an “aggressive” and threatening manner by throwing his jacket on the ground and telling passengers he did not care if he went to jail, prompting Penny to take action.
A Manhattan medical examiner ruled Neely’s death a homicide in May 2023, further prompting Bragg to press charges against Penny. The now-dismissed manslaughter charge came with a potential 15-year prison sentence, while the negligent homicide charges comes with a maximum four-year sentence.
In a separate case, Bragg charged President-elect Donald Trump with 34 counts of falsifying business records to cover up an $130,000 hush money payment to former porn actress Stormy Daniels ahead of the 2016 election. A jury convicted Trump on every felony count in May, though Judge Juan Merchan indefinitely delayed the sentencing date following the election and permitted the president-elect’s legal team to file a motion to dismiss the case.
All content created by the Daily Caller News Foundation, an independent and nonpartisan newswire service, is available without charge to any legitimate news publisher that can provide a large audience. All republished articles must include our logo, our reporter’s byline and their DCNF affiliation. For any questions about our guidelines or partnering with us, please contact [email protected].
Mark Zuckerberg Claims Facebook Is Ditching “Fact-Checkers” and Going to Community Notes Similar to 𝕏
by JD Rucker
Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg is a scoundrel, a billionaire snake who has backstabbed pretty much everyone he’s personally dealt with ever since rising to prominence. He spent over $400 million of his own money to prevent President Donald Trump from winning in 2020. His “platform” has been amongst the most…
Bill O’Reilly to Donald Trump: “The Press Hates You”
by Podcaster
There has been a very noticeable shift in the way legacy media is covering the transition for President Trump compared to his first victory in 2016. It seems that many in legacy media are toning down their rhetoric and preparing to treat President Trump more “fairly.” According to Bill O’Reilly,…
The Biggest Sale on Beef With 25-Year Shelf-Life EVER
by Sponsored Post
Let’s cut to the chase. Prepper All-Naturals is offering an unprecedented 40% off for its “Beef Steak” survival bags with promo code “steak40”. With a 25-year shelf life and a single ingredient (beef, of course), our most popular product is available for a very limited time with the biggest discount…
The Climate Agenda’s March Through the Institutions: Can It Be Stopped?
by Daily Signal
A spate of stories in the media recently provides a remarkable illustration of how the globalist policy agenda of the climate-industrial complex has captured key international institutions and perverted their original organizational aims. From initially serving broad, laudable objectives for the welfare of their constituents, these institutions have been subverted…
About That Video of Deb Fischer’s Husband and Kamala Harris That’s Circulating on Social Media
by Red State
Social media platforms can be bowls of dumb on any given day (that goes double for BlueSky), and Monday was no exception, with the certification of Donald Trump’s November election victory bringing out some fresh cray-cray from Democrats and their media allies. Though the President-Elect certainly does bring out the…
Trump Denies “Fake News” Report on Changes to Economic Plans
by Publius
President-elect Donald Trump has refuted a Washington Post report suggesting his aides were considering a more restrained tariff policy. The report claimed that Trump’s transition team was contemplating a tariff plan that would be less extensive than his campaign promises, targeting only imports deemed critical to national or economic security….
Radicalized Knife-Wielding Man Attempts to Storm Belgian Prime Minister’s Offices Shouting ‘Allah Akbar’
by RAIR Foundation
Brussels, Belgium — January 6, 2025: A potentially deadly attack was narrowly avoided this morning when a “radicalized” man in his twenties armed with a knife attempted to break into the offices of Belgian Prime Minister Alexander De Croo. The incident occurred at 16 rue de la Loi as the…
Gold Breaks Out With Central Bank Surge and Interest Rate Drops Expected
by Sponsored Post
Precious metals are seeing gains once again following the post-election dip, just as many economists had expected. Even China, which had been holding back for five months, returned to purchasing massive quantities of gold. “Falling U.S. interest rates and ongoing solid demand from central banks are supporting the gold price,”…
JPMorgan: “Debasement Trade” Into Bitcoin and Gold Is Here to Stay
by Tyler Durden, Zero Hedge
(Zero Hedge)—The so-called “debasement trade” into gold and Bitcoin is “here to stay” as investors brace for persistent geopolitical uncertainty, according to a Jan. 3 research note by JPMorgan shared with CoinTelegraph. Gold and BTC “appear to have become more important components of investors’ portfolios structurally” as they increasingly seek to…
Study of 9 Million Exposes ‘Devastating’ Neurological Damage Surge Among Covid-Vaxxed
by Slay News
An explosive new study involving almost 9 million participants has exposed a devasted surge in deadly neurological and psychiatric damage among those who received Covid mRNA “vaccines.” According to the peer-reviewed study, just one dose of an mRNA injection puts recipients at risk of suffering several severe neurological diseases. The…
More Details Emerge Regarding the Plan to Kill a Supreme Court Justice
by Zachary Stieber, The Epoch Times
(The Epoch Times)—A California man allegedly told authorities that he flew to the East Coast to kill Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh, according to newly filed court documents. Nicholas Roske flew across the country from California to Virginia on June 7, 2022, landing just before midnight. He got into a…
First US Death From H5N1 Bird Flu Reported in Louisiana
by Infowars
On the same day Congress certified Trump’s election victory – and with just 14 days before he takes office – the official confirmation of the nation’s first “H5N1-related human death” has been reported in Louisiana. Notably, authorities have made it clear that all we will know about the diseased patient…
Embracing Natural Foods: A Path to Better Health and Healing
by Local News
A diet high in natural foods has many benefits, from reducing the risk of disease and obesity to the vitamins and nutrients that natural foods contain that can aid in the healing of certain health conditions or diagnoses. Using natural foods in our diets is vital for Americans to become…
Dana White Has Joined Meta’s Board of Directors
by Cactus Williams, Discern Report
UFC CEO and long-time friend of Donald Trump, Dana White, has joined Meta’s board of directors alongside Charlie Songhurst and John Elkann. This is just the latest in a series of decisions Meta has made following Trump’s historic electoral victory which seemed to be aimed at cozying up to the…
